AI in schools – is that the question?

AI

By Madeleine Champagnie, Head of English and Innovation

Screen time vs books; social media vs time in nature; AI vs human creativity. Parents and carers in the late 2020s battle these binaries within their families against the constantly strident debate over the education of their children and teenagers. Similar to the urgency and suddenness of the pandemic, schools have been tasked with immediately adapting to AI whilst still teaching within a system which has not changed much since the slide rule was the latest tech in maths lessons. 

Meanwhile, the conflation of all things vaguely technological as a monolithic “problem” to be resolved in education runs apace with increasing demands for exam access arrangements, such as the use of a laptop for typing, or a computer reader. Young people also need to develop the intelligent use of these technologies, which are now the substrate in every workplace. In another pandemic parallel, teachers thus experience contradictory demands: don’t use technology! But also, pupils must use laptops to practise for their exams and futures! Don’t allow youth near AI; but also, you should be using AI to differentiate resources! 

Neither luddite nor technofuturist, at Thames Christian School we have chosen a holistic rather than a binary approach. Teaching at Thames has always involved a blend of both analogue and digital, since our inception as a Google reference school back in 2012. Pupils remain free to choose paper over keyboard in class or at home and teachers have been asked to include non-screen options in homeworks, where possible. We do not use AI or EdTech unless it clearly demonstrates pedagogical enhancement or support for learning. The same attitude applies to analogue methods which could alienate pupils such as copying from the board or laboriously hand producing formats which detract from critical or analytical thinking.

Nevertheless, the advent of AI cannot be ignored. Our own internal school surveys have demonstrated the same results as external studies: that young people are wholesale using AI whether we ask them to or not. They are not all rushing to cheat. They want staff to be in control, intentionally teaching and modelling good use of AI. Teachers cannot do that unless we understand it ourselves. The range of uses of AI has mushroomed and continues to grow at an impossible rate, but there are several external organisations whose oversight and guidance are invaluable for schools navigating the complexity.

One is the Good Future Foundation which awards the AI quality mark to schools for thoughtful, ethical and constructive use of AI. From Progress then Bronze through to Gold, schools can use the award as a way to comprehensively audit AI adoption from the classroom to the school office. 

Another is Educate Ventures Research, led by Professor Rose Luckin, whose mantra Learn fast, implement more slowly feels resoundingly correct. EVR’s recently published research, Human Intelligence First: the Tool is the Smallest Part, unpicks the rigid binary debate, serving evidence of a more nuanced reality in nine schools. Notably, the study at Thames Christian School, one of the nine, showed that two things can be true at once: pupils appreciated the precision and speed of AI feedback on their writing. They also preferred teacher feedback. 

Polarised, or holistic? 

Humans are complex beings: perhaps this is why reductive reasoning fails to spur progress or deepen understanding when disruptive events or technologies like AI impact education. The questions we need to ask ourselves about the use of AI in education could be flipped: rather than Will AI harm cognition,criticality or creativity in growing minds? one could ask How do we facilitate the ignition of creative and critical intelligence when young people use AI, a computer or pen and paper? Artificial Intelligence (or digital or superintelligence or whatever we call it next) without human wisdom and creativity is perhaps like “…an unweeded garden that grows to seed; things rank and gross in nature possess it merely.” (Hamlet Act I, Scene 2). Without us as the designers, producers, growers, it becomes entirely, (which is the 16th century meaning of ‘merely’),

uncontrolled. Do we stick our heads in the soil, or do we roll up our sleeves and teach digital gardening techniques? The metaphor fits, yet we should also take it literally. Not just AI, technology and the like, but also books, handwriting and yes – physical gardening. 

And yet, another dimension is lacking. Abstracting beyond AI, Pope Leo provokes more profoundly: 

“…the key issue is not the use of technology as such, but the vision that underlies it. If the human being is treated as something to be perfected or surpassed, it becomes easier to accept that some lives are less useful, less desirable or less worthy. …scientific and technological advances, when detached from moral and social progress, end up turning against humanity. [130] For this reason, a clear distinction must be made. It is one thing to integrate technology within a human-centered, relational vision; it is quite another to be guided by an outlook that devalues human limits and promises a purely technical form of “salvation.”” (Magnifica Humanitas, para 117.)
An idea that parents, carers and teachers should ponder before worrying about AI in education, therefore, is this: What does this school believe about the value of my child? An economic bio-unit to be optimised, or something more? That, perhaps, is the question.

Book a tour

The best way to find out more about Thames Christian School is to visit us for a tour and talk to our staff and pupils.

Please book a personal appointment by calling the office on 020 7228 3933 or emailing admissions@thameschristianschool.org.uk or click on the contact button below to fill in an online form.

Contact us